Alright guys, thanks for coming. We’re gonna look at some important information and advice about how to read and answer the comparison question in AQA GCSE English Language Paper 2, question 2. I mean… we will when Gale stops eating all my teaching materials.

What’s the Problem with GCSE English Language Paper 2 Question 2?

The problem is basically that the wording is really sneaky. Every question will ask for a summary of both Texts A and B. Simple, right? Nope, a summary is usually both similarities and differences, but they are asking for something more specific.

Example Questions from Past Papers

• A) “Use details from both sources to write a summary of what you understand about the differences between the two trains.” 

• B) “Use details from both sources to write a summary of what you understand about the similar behaviour of the drivers.”

Example A is extremely similar to example B, but they are asking for different things (and I’m already tired of the word ‘different’). Although you are always asked to give a summary of the information, they will always want just the similarities or just the differences. So, not what most people think when writing a summary.

Also, notice how example B is only asking for information about similar behaviour. So be careful to only write about behaviour and nothing else.

Will I Lose Marks if I Write about the Wrong One?

It’s difficult to say because the marking scheme considers similarities and differences that are valid and well summarised are equally good answers, however… you are being assessed at all times on your accuracy and ability to read and interpret the questions you are asked. Basically, I wouldn’t chance it. I would stick to exactly what they ask for at all times, especially when asked to only comment on something like the “similar behaviour” of the drivers. This is a good example of how talking about anything other than the drivers’ behaviour will not get you any marks.

Luckily I don’t have to chance it because I’m not taking my GCSEs, because I’m a goblin and I live in a damp mud pile in the forest. But the dirt doesn't stop Gale, does it? Geez, I must have really offended God in a previous life.